Environmentalchristian’s Weblog

Discussing the world around us

Arsenic Poisoning

arsenic.gifArsenic is a common natural and anthropogenic contaminant in sediments, surface waters, and ground waters. In Taiwan, Bangladesh, and the United States arsenic poisoning has been linked to disorders such as hyperpigmentation (Black-foot disease), Peripheral Vascular Disease, skin and bladder cancer, and gangrene 2,3. Sporadic occurrences of Black-foot disease occurred in southwest Taiwan in the early twentieth century with a peak incidence in the late fifty’s 2. The cause of this arsenic poisoning was due to resident’s use of contaminated artesian wells 2. Arsenic poisoning incidents reduced significantly when residents began switching to tap water in the endemic villages 2. Awareness of this outbreak caused the EPA cancer risk assessment to use the cancer data from Southwest Taiwan to predict the cancer risk assessment in the United States 4,6. Recently changes in water quality standards in America along with greater understanding of arsenic toxicity have increased the necessity for methods of determining potentially bioavailable arsenic in field environments as well as characterization in natural environments.arsenic-hands.jpg

Complex geochemical and biological mechanisms control the distribution of arsenic within repositories in the biosphere, hydrosphere, and lithosphere. Arsenic in water is primarily found in two oxidation states, As (III) and As (V) 1. As (III) is considered more toxic than As (V), and is generally less mobile. Therefore, under many conditions As sequestion is undergone through reduction. This, however, is problematic because reducing environments release arsenic from arsenic bearing minerals such as oxyhydroxides. This is exactly what happened in Bangladesh when buried deposits of peat acted as electron donors for the reduction of arsenic bearing Goethite into the groundwaters3. Controls on the distribution of arsenic include: redox conditions, pH, presence of Iron and Manganese Oxyhydroxides, and metabolic activities of microorganisms. Iron oxides, however, generally control arsenic speciation in near-surface environments 1. Iron, when present, in the environment, controls the mobility, fate, and bioavailability of aqueous arsenic species by converting bioavailable arsenite (AsO33-) and arsenate (AsO43-) species to immobilized forms adsorbed or coprecipitated in iron oxides 1. Chemical availability of As is an indirect measure of bioavailability. Bioavailability refers to the concentration of a target chemical that actually enters the systemic circulation of an organism from an administered dose5. (commonly considered the total concentration of the chemical present in the organism’s environment). It is generally assumed that dissolved phases are most bioavailable 5. Chemical availability of As is dependent on speciation. Therefore, when the speciation of arsenic in a soil system is known the chemical availability becomes a good indicator of bioavailability.

The World Health Organization estimates that 41 million people worldwide (some sources estimate 57 million) are drinking groundwater contaminated by arsenic at unsafe levels 10. In Taiwan alone approximately 2 million people are potentially exposed to polluted water 9. Arsenic, although rare in natural abundance in the lithosphere, is common in sulfides such as chalcopyrite, realgar, orpiment, galena, marcasite, arsenopyrite, enargite, and it has a strong affinity for pyrite, one of the world’s most common minerals 9. It is also common in other minerals through substitution. Arsenic in groundwater is often the result of dissolving weathered rock and soils or through reduction of iron oxides. In the case of the massive epidemic in Bangladesh the arsenic is released to the groundwater through goethite (FeOOH) reduction 4. Which is driven by microbial degradation of buried deposits of peat. The peat acts as an electron donor so that iron oxide reduction can take place.

Arsenic is often added to groundwater through anthropogenic sources such as use in alloying agents, wood preservatives, mineral extraction and processing wastes, poultry and swine feed additives, pesticides, and highly soluble arsenic trioxide stockpiles 1,9. The most globally significant anthropomorphic source of arsenic is probably through combustion of fossil fuels 12. The arsenic mainly appears as arsenite in the dust and travels through the atmosphere releasing arsenic throughout the globe. In 1988 Nriagu and Pacyna estimated that as much 70% of the global atmospheric As flux is anthropogenic. In the past arsenic acid was even used as a cotton defoliant in the southern part of the United States 11.

Globally, millions of people are at risk for the adverse effects of arsenic exposure. Contaminated drinking water is usually contaminated through inorganic arsenic. Inorganic arsenic is more acutely toxic that organic arsenic species 2,3. Other countries than Taiwan and Bangladesh that currently face arsenic exposure include: Argentina, Cambodia, Chile, China, Ghana, Hungary, India, Mexico, Vietnam, Tibet, Thailand, as well as the United States 1,2,3,9. As the world population increases beyond 6 billion clean drinking water is quickly becoming one of globe’s most valuable resources. In order to protect our drinking water we must continue to study and understand contaminants of all varieties. This is a fundamental mission and goal of the applicant’s research group at Texas A&M University. This project will directly aid in this endeavor. Additionally, the international component to the proposed research will serve as a reminder to the scientific community of the importance in scientific collaboration and goodwill across global borders in solving the world’s environmental issues.

 This post is an excerpt from a copywritten article written by Clint Miller. All quotes must be cited to me.

Evaluating Arsenic Availability in Taiwanese Soils using DOWEX M4195, Fe3+ Substituted, Resin; Clint Miller; NSF EAPSI Grant Application; 2007

References

1. A review of the source, behaviour and distribution of arsenic in natural waters; P.L. Smedley*, D.G. Kinniburgh, Applied Geochemistry 17 (2002) 517-568

2. Long-term arsenic exposure and ischemic heart disease in arseniasis-hyperendemic villages in Taiwan, Chin-Hsiao Tseng, Choon-Khim Chong, Ching-Ping Tseng, Yu-Mei Hsueh, Hung-Yi Chiou, Ching-Chung Tseng, and Chien-Jen Chen; Toxicology Letters, Volume 137, Issues 1-2, 31 January 2003, Pages 15-21

3. Arsenic poisoning in groundwater: Health risk and geochemical sources in Bangladesh, H. M. Anawar, J. Akai, K. M. G. Mostofa, S. Safiullah, and S. M. Tareq; Environment International, Volume 27, Issue 7, February 2002, Pages 597-604

4. Significance of Exposure Assessment to Analysis of Cancer Risk from Inorganic Arsenic in Drinking Water in Taiwan; Kenneth G. Brown and Chien-Jen Chen; Risk Analysis, Volume 15 Issue 4 Page 475-484, August 1995

5. An In Vitro Gastrointestinal Method To Estimate Bioavailable Arsenic in Contaminated Soils and Solid Media; Rodriguez, R. R.; Basta, N. T.; Casteel, S.; S. W.; Pace, L. W.; Environmental Science & Technology, 1999, 33, 642-649

6. Inorganic arsenic: a need and an opportunity to improve risk assessment; W R Chappell, B D Beck, K G Brown, R Chaney, R Cothern, C R Cothern, K J Irgolic, D W North, I Thornton, and T A Tsongas; Environ Health Perspect. 1997 October; 105(10): 1060-1067.

7. Quantification of Potential Arsenic Bioavailability in Spatially Varying Geologic Environments at the Watershed Scale using Chelating Resins; Lake, G. E.; M.A. Thesis, Texas A&M University, 2002), 227 pp

8. Assessment of the phytotoxicity of chromium in soils using the selective ion exchange resin extraction method; Pei-Fang Yu, Kai-Wei Juang and Dar-Yuan Lee; Plant and Soil 258: 333-340, 2004.

9. Contamination of drinking-water by arsenic in Bangladesh: a public health emergency; Allan H. Smith; Elena O. Lingas; Mahfuzar Rahman; Bulletin of the World Health Organization; Print ISSN 0042-9686; Bull World Health Organ vol. 78 no. 9 Genebra 2000

10. Worldwide Occurrences of Arsenic in Ground Water; D. Kirk Nordstrom, SCIENCE VOL 296, 21 JUNE 2002; 2143-2145

11. Occurrence and Distribution of Arsenic in Soils and Plants; Leo M. Walsh; Malcolm E. Sumner; Dennis R. Keeney; Environmental Health Perspectives, Vol. 19. (Aug., 1977), pp. 67-71

12. Quantitative assessment of worldwide contamination of air, water, and soils by trace metals; Nriagu, J.O., Pacyna, J.M., Nature 333, 134-139; 1988

February 29, 2008 - Posted by environmentalchristian | Contaminants, Environment | , , , , | 5 Comments

5 Comments »

  1. Wow, I have been reading about Arsenic in Bangladesh. It is amazing how widespread the problem is.

    Comment by Jim | February 29, 2008

  2. There seems little doubt that Arsenic is material in some instances of Bladder Cancer – from the Arsenic skin lightener creams used by The pharoes and evidence that they seem to have had Prostate Cancer – I would contend that this is misdiagnosis of Bladder Cancer.
    Also take note of the high instance of BC amongst those who work with timber in the building industry in America where Arsenic is used as a preservative.
    etc. etc. see http://www.UrologyCancerResource.com

    Regards, Greg L-W. any further info. would be appreciated.

    Comment by Greg L-W. | March 1, 2008

  3. please see my web log and remain a massage & please tell me which method you use to determine arsenic in water river.
    B.R.
    siamak

    Comment by siamak Gholami | July 17, 2008

  4. Hi Clint. We have got millions yes millions of tons of peat being removed from 400 acres (2 meters deep), next door to us. The dust is affecting residents for miles around. My partner has become progressively ill over the last few months with lethargy (me too) and loss of apetite and digestive discomfort as well a some other bits and pieces. I have been told that some of the workers have been told not make contact with any ground water as it has arsenic in it. Are you interested in knowing any more. I am running a food bussiness and am a bit concerned that the black dust that settles on the tables may be contaminated.

    Comment by steve carter | February 22, 2009

  5. Hi, this comment is for Clint Miller and anyone else that would like to give me some feedback. ^ months ago I was diagnosed with ITP (low platelets in blood) My platelets go to a critical low levels. I have been hospitalized at least 10 times in the past 4 months because of this condition. Searching for an answer, Doctors at UCLA have found high levels of arsenic in my urine/blood. (239.8) They believe that working for an airline for 22 yrs and breathing those fumes -day in and day out- is one of the reazons of this high arsenic. They have also discovered -granulomas- in my lungs.
    Here’s my point… in 22 yrs the airline that I work for, has never gaven me any information as how dangerous to my healt is to breath those aircraft fumes. The have never mentioned how dagerous is to my skin.
    The Airline doesn’t have any training or advise available for employees. They dont even have signs (like gas stations do) saying that “this enviroment cound couse birth defects or cancer”
    So, I thing it would be VERY interesting for someone like you to initiate an investigation of what I call the -missing link-
    Airlines are very worried about OSHA and regulations compliance but in reality, airlines -stop- the flow of communication to the employee when it comes to issues that potentially could have monetary implications.
    According to OSHA, all airlines MUST inform employees about risks and possibilities of developping an illness due to a working anviroment.
    In 22 yers I have never seen anything from my airline stating the aircraft fumes contain significant levels of arsenic. Or aircraft fumes are poison to your health and could couse cancer. Or, Exposure to high levels of arsenic can cause death. Exposure to arsenic at low levels for extended periods of time can cause a discoloration of the skin and the appearance of small corns or warts. Or, Smelter workers, exposed to concentrations of arsenic up to 7 mg As/m3, showed an increased
    incidence in nasal septal perforation, rhinopharyngolaryngitis, tracheobronchitis, and pulmonary
    insufficiency (Lundgren, 1954; as cited in U.S. EPA, 1984).
    Or,The workers were found to have a statistically significant correlation between cumulative
    exposure to arsenic and reduced nerve conduction velocities in three peripheral nerves (upper
    and lower extremities). Slightly reduced nerve conduction velocity in 2 or more peripheral
    nerves was reported as “more common” among arsenic exposed workers.
    Please let me know your thoughts…
    Thanks to all, that have found the time to participate.
    Robert.

    Comment by Robert | March 1, 2009


Leave a comment